A place to explore and buy perennial vegetables and other food plants.
Two popular perennial brassicas, Taunton Deane kale and purple tree collard, can look quite similar when young. Sometimes gardeners plant them out and then wonder which is which. So I thought a few comparison photos of the young plants growing in tubs in our backyard might be handy.
Taunton Deane kale is on the left and the purple tree collard is on the right.

Taunton Deane kale leaf.

Purple tree collard leaf.

Taunton Deane kale upper stem

Purple tree collard upper stem

Taunton Deane kale lower stem

Purple tree collard lower stem

The photos aren’t definitive of course. Individual plants can vary and growing conditions can affect leaf and stem colour and size etc. But I’d say these plants are fairly typical of how the two varieties look when we grow them here.
Taunton Deane kale and purple tree collard become far more distinct from each other as they get older. In my garden at least, the purple tree collard grows to a height of 180-210cm with a woody stem about 4cm in diameter. It is a rather lanky plant and its branches have a habit of partially breaking off near the trunk and drooping towards the ground. They then start to curve skyward again.

Purple tree collard
Taunton Deane kale grows to about 150-180cm. (But the height of both plants is restrained by the nibbling of pigeons – which also effects a flat-top appearance on the Taunton Deane). Taunton Deane cannot be described as lanky – it develops a stout trunk (about 8cm diameter on my four year old plant), and its thicker side branches rarely break and drop.

Taunton Deane kale
Whilst both plants have purple hues, the purple tree collard leaves are capable of turning a much deeper purple than those of Taunton Deane. I have observed this in cold weather but also in summer – so can’t confidently say yet what conditions produce it.
Purple tree collards are only hardy to about -5 or -6 degrees C. I’m not sure how low a temperature Taunton Deane kale can take but it is definitely the hardier of the two.
I hope that’s useful.
Maxine
Really interesting read.
I have both plants.
But they are still babies and I can tell them apart.
I have a weird thing to grow purple veg.
Pete
My observations of these two plants are generally the same with yours. Occasionally I have difficulty to distinguish the young plants of these two varieties. The leaves of some of my rooted kales look like Taunton Deane kale but the stems look like purple tree collard. My mature Taunton Deane kale plants occasionally also produce lanky drooping branches, most likely due to the search of sunlight.
Alison Tindale
Indeed I do have to label my trays of cuttings very carefully and, having done so, have to just push away any subsequent doubts I have when looking at them as they grow!
Pippa
I have one plant of each growing in the greenhouse atm and they look so similar if not looking at them too hard.
I have also taken a cutting from each and didn’t label them! ohps.
Also, I have noticed that the tree collard is sending out a lot more side shoots than the Taunton Dean kale, that only seemed to have one or two.